Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 09 JUNE 2009

Insurance/Reinsurance Bulletin, June 2009

HFW
HFW
Contributor
HFW

HFW

HFW is a sector-focused law firm with people who have a real passion for the sectors they work in,...

View firm profile
Explore more from HFW

In this unusual case, the Court of Appeal ruled that reinsurer (Allianz) allegations of fraud against the North Korean state-owned insurer, KNIC, are “justiciable” (i.e. capable of being tried in England), and therefore capable of forming a defence to KNIC’s reinsurance claim, despite the potential of those allegations to cause diplomatic embarrassment between the UK and North Korea.

United KingdomInsurance

Reinsurance Fraud Allegations Are Justiciable
Korea National Insurance Corporation v Allianz Global

By Andrew Bandurka

In this unusual case, the Court of Appeal ruled that reinsurer (Allianz) allegations of fraud against the North Korean state-owned insurer, KNIC, are "justiciable" (i.e. capable of being tried in England), and therefore capable of forming a defence to KNIC's reinsurance claim, despite the potential of those allegations to cause diplomatic embarrassment between the UK and North Korea.

Overcoming Allianz' allegation of fraud, KNIC had obtained judgment in the North Korean court against Allianz, in accordance with the jurisdiction clause in the reinsurance contract, and sought to enforce the judgment in the UK. Allianz alleged the judgment had been procured by a fraud, instigated or approved by the North Korean Government with KNIC's knowledge or participation, and that the judgment was unenforceable on public policy grounds since the North Korean

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from