In a construction dispute between the subcontractor and the main
contractor under an Abu Dhabi seated arbitration, the chairman of a
tribunal was challenged for failing to allow equal opportunities to
the parties in presenting their case, whilst issuing various
procedural directions purportedly on behalf of the tribunal.
The relevant arbitration authority reviewing the challenge,
rejected the reasons argued therein but nevertheless removed the
said chairman from the tribunal on the basis of procedural
irregularities that were not pleaded in the challenge but were
nevertheless independently identified.
Reasons for the Challenge
The challenge was submitted against the chairman of the tribunal
because circumstances arose raising doubts over his neutrality or
independence which became known after the chairman's
appointment, as detailed below.