There have been conflicting judgments in regard to whether a
notice of intention to except in terms of Rule 23(1) of the High
Court Rules is an appropriate response to a notice of bar. In March
2012, in the case of McNally NO and Others v Codron and
Others, the Western Cape High Court held that a party is
precluded from delivering a notice of intention to except on the
basis that the pleading is vague and embarrassing upon receipt of a
notice of bar.
In Felix and Another v Nortier NO and Others, the
Eastern Cape High Court held that the filing of a notice of
intention to except is permissible in response to a notice of
bar.
In Landmark Mthatha (Pty) Ltd v King Sabata Dalinyebo
Municipality and Others: In re: Africa Earthworks (Pty) Ltd v
Landmark Mthatha (Pty) Ltd and Others, the Court in the
Eastern Cape followed the approach adopted in
the Felix case.