In Sportscene Mthatha v Nondumiso Myataza, the Eastern Cape Division of the High Court, Mthatha, was called upon to determine questions of costs de bonis propriis (fees being payable from a practitioner’s own pocket rather than from their clients) and fee forfeiture against legal practitioners following the collapse of a full bench appeal.
Background
The underlying dispute concerned a slip-and-fall claim in which Ms Myataza alleged that she had slipped on a wet mat at the entrance of Sportscene, sustaining severe injuries to her leg, back and neck due to Sportscene’s negligence. The court of first instance found in favour of Ms Myataza and ordered Sportscene to pay damages.
Sportscene noted an appeal, but when the matter came before a Full Bench on 29 April 2025, it became apparent that the appeal record was grossly deficient. Critical photographs, which had been referred to by various witnesses at the trial, and which were central to the evidence, were either poorly photocopied or