When a judge confronts perceived irregularities in settled
litigation, how far may the judge go without crossing the line into
professional misconduct? This article examines a recent ruling of
the Judicial Conduct Committee ("JCC"),
concerning an appeal lodged in terms of the Judicial Service
Commission Act, which shed guidance on good-faithed decisions made
by a judicial official, but which ultimately constitute judicial
error and overreach, amount to wilful or grossly negligent
misconduct and sanctionable consequences under the Judicial Service
Commission Act.
Background and procedural history
This matter stemmed from a formal complaint lodged by De Broglio
Attorneys Inc. against Fisher J of the Gauteng Division of the High
Court arising from two civil matters -Taylor v Road Accident
Fund and Mathonsi v Road Accident Fund - which were
heard together by Fischer J. Although the plaintiffs and the RAF
had reached a settlement, Fisher J questioned the propriety