Generally, when a person approaches the Court with a prayer, he
is expected to do so with clean hands. The same applies in case of
infringement matters too. If an individual has been refrained from
using a mark, he/she cannot bring an action against another for
infringement of that mark. This is what the Division Bench of the
Delhi High Court laid down in Ansul Industries v. Vineet
Kumar, wherein the Appellant had challenged the order of
the Single Judge restraining it from getting interim relief against
the Respondents for the use of the mark 'Udta Panchhi'.
BRIEF FACTS OF THE CASE:
Ansul Industries, the Appellant herein had been restrained,
directly and indirectly from dealing with chewing tobacco under the
Trade Mark 'Udta Panchhi' and/or any other mark that would
be identical and/or deceptively similar to the Trade Mark of M/s.
Shiva Tobacco Co., Ambala, i.e., 'Panchhi'. A compromise
decree had however been passed and the company had accepted and
recognized the