The decision of the Delhi High Court in Trident
Limited vs Controller of Patents [C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT)
162/2022] addresses a recurring issue in Indian
patent cases, as to how inventive step under Section 2(1)(ja) of
the Patents Act, 1970 is to be assessed, particularly in cases
where an invention emerges from a known technological field but
claims a distinct technical outcome. The judgment examines whether
an invention can be dismissed as obvious merely because it employs
known processes or materials, or whether the technical effect and
outcome achieved by the invention must be independently
evaluated.
The judgment further examines how it is crucial to clearly
establish obviousness when common general knowledge points away
from the claimed invention. At the heart of the dispute were
allegations of hindsight bias in patent examination and the failure
of the Patent Office to demonstrate a clear and reasoned pathway
from the prior art to the claimed invention, as the