On 17 January 2020, by its ruling numbered (2019) Jing 04 Min Te
135 (Ruling), the Beijing Fourth Intermediate
People's Court (Beijing Court) upheld the
validity of an arbitration agreement in a prospectus for a
short-term financing bond which also contains conflicting
litigation clauses.
In the Ruling, the Beijing Court followed the opinion of the
Supreme People's Court of China (SPC),
reversing the lower court's initial conclusion. The SPC opined
that, where a contract contains different dispute resolution
clauses in different sections, the parties' "last
expression of intent" prevails.
Background
In October 2017, Beijing Huaye Capital Holdings Co., Ltd. issued
a prospectus for its RMB500 million short-term financing bond. The
term of the bond is 365 days. On 2 August 2018, Guangzhou
Securities Co., Ltd. purchased the bond at par value for RMB50
million according to the terms of the Prospectus.