102751 Canada Inc. v. L'Agence du Revenu du
Québec
Revenu Québec refused certain business expenses claimed
by the defendant (the Taxpayer) for the 2005 to 2010 taxation
years, as well as for 2012. The Taxpayer objected to each yearly
assessments (the Notice of Assessment) in a timely manner and began
legal proceedings to appeal them before the Court. While the appeal
was still pending, the Taxpayer filed an amended return requesting
to carry back losses incurred in 2015 to the 2012 taxation year.
Revenu Québec served the Taxpayer with a new notice of
assessment (the Notice of Reassessment) for the 2012 taxation year,
to which the Taxpayer did not formally object. When the appeal was
ultimately brought before the Court, Revenu Québec submitted
that the appeal for the 2012 fiscal period was inadmissible given
that the Notice of Assessment that the Taxpayer had objected to
ceased to exist following the issuance of the Notice of
Reassessment. According to Revenu Québec,