In Harris v Bayerische Motoren Werke
Aktiengesellschaft, the Ontario Superior Court
of Justice articulated the high standard that a manufacturer must
reach to avoid certification in a product liability case on the
basis that there is "no danger" arising from an admitted
defect.1 The Court certified a class action against
BMW on behalf of all persons or entities in Canada who are or were
owners or lessees of certain Mini Cooper Vehicles which were
impacted by a power steering issue that could cause a loss of power
steering or fire.
BMW admitted that the electro-hydraulic power steering system in
the affected vehicles was defective for a period of time and could
fail. However, BMW attempted to resist certification by denying
that the resulting loss of power steering was dangerous because the
vehicle would simply revert to manual steering mode. In rejecting
these arguments, the Court described the manufacturer's
resistance to certification as "futile,"
"arrogant," and