This is a case that became something of a lightning rod in the
storm of subscriber privacy rights vs. copyright. As we wrote in
our
earlier post, a copyright owner can
only enforce its rights against online infringement if it knows the
identity of the infringer. It can seek a court order (called a
Norwich order) to disclose the identity of those alleged
infringers. Canadian law is clear that "A court order is
required in every case as a condition precedent to the release of
subscriber information."
Such an order was used by Voltage Pictures to obtain the names
and addresses of some 2,000 subscribers of an ISP known TekSavvy
Solutions Inc. TekSavvy sought reimbursement of its costs for
complying with the order: TekSavvy claimed recovery of a total of
$346,480.68. Voltage offered to pay $884.00. The lower court
concluded that Voltage should pay $21,557.50 to cover
TekSavvy's legal costs, administrative costs, and disbursements
of abiding with the Order.