Thinking of patenting, but waiting for some customers first?
Tread carefully. By merely offering your invention for sale,
even if the invention has not even been manufactured, you may
lose patent rights.
The recent US case of Hamliton Beach v. Sunbeam
Products Inc. (Case No. 11-CV-0345, Decided:
August 14, 2013) dealt with a challenge to Hamilton Beach's
patent for a slow-cooker design. The critical event was
a transaction between Hamilton Beach and a foreign supplier in
early 2005. The offer occurred before the patent
filing date - to be specific, it occurred more than 1 year before
the filing date. This offer by Hamilton Beach was considered
by the court to be an offer for sale of a product that anticipated
the asserted claims and the court found that the invention
was ready for patenting prior to the relevant date. The court noted
that "An actual sale is not required for the activity to be an
invalidating commercial offer for sale... An attempt to sell