In the case of Bowman
v. Monsanto Company (May 13, 2013), the US Supreme Court
has weighed into this thorny field, and on Monday it delivered a
unanimous judgment upholding the rights in Monsanto's patented
soybeans. (See our earlier post: Self-Replicating Technologies
(Patents in the Field, Part 2).)
Monsanto sells its patented seeds under a license agreement.
Farmers are permitted to plant the beans in one, and only one,
growing season. Collection and replanting is prohibited under the
terms of the license. Bowman bought seeds from a local grain
elevantor, planted, harvested, collected and replanted those
seeds in successive years. In this way, he was able to take
advantage of the "Round-Up Ready" qualities of the
genetically modified beans, without paying the usual fee that would
be owed to Monsanto as the patent owner. In the court's view,
this deprived Monsanto of the reward that patent law provides for
the sale of each patented article. The court was clear