Can a prior disclosure of an invention be fatal to a patent? And
if so, what constitutes "disclosure" of the
invention.
One of the central pillars of patentability is
"novelty" - the invention must be new, the first of its
kind in the world. If it's not new, the patent application will
fail or (if discovered after the patent has issued) the patent
itself can be invalidated. Wenzel Downhole Tools Ltd. v.
National-Oilwell Canada Ltd., 2011 FC 1323
(CanLII) is an interesting judgement dealing with a device that
was manufactured and rented to a third party for use in drilling an
oil well in Texas prior to the relevant date of the Canadian
patent. This earlier device invalidated the patent, since it
constituted an "enabling disclosure" of the invention
more than 12 months prior to filing of the patent application. In
this case, to prove when the earlier device was invented and
disclosed, an expert was called in to examine the metadata for the
design drawings, to verify