The Law of Taking was Fishy
If you give a man a fish, you feed him for a day.
If you teach a man to fish, you feed him for a
lifetime.
But what if a man has the right to sell fish, and he builds his
business and livelihood around that right, and then the government
passes a law allowing only the government to sell fish, putting him
out of business?
In a nutshell, that's the backdrop for a 1979 Supreme Court
of Canada (SCC) decision calledManitoba Fisheries Ltd. v. The
Queen1 [Manitoba Fisheries].
In 1969 parliament passed legislation2 which granted
a crown corporation a commercial monopoly on the export of fish
from the province of Manitoba (Manitoba), but in doing so, allowed
that crown corporation the ability to grant licenses to private
corporations—corporations like Manitoba Fisheries—to
continue operating in the business of exporting fish. However,
Manitoba refused to grant Manitoba Fisheries the license to allow
it to continue business, and so the