David v Abdishou [2012] NSWCA 109
New South Wales Court of Appeal1
In Brief
- The Court discussed the underlying principles that must be
proved to establish any case in defamation.
- Often a defamation case can rely on the presumption that where
a document has been made publicly available someone is likely to
have read and understood it.
- However, in certain factual circumstances this presumption can
be defeated with sufficient evidence.
Background
This appeal arose from a claim in defamation that was heard
before a jury and raised issues regarding the basic elements that
need to be shown in order to establish a claim in defamation.
The plaintiffs, Fred and Suzy David were solicitors who, along
with many, if not all, of the defendants, were of Assyrian origin.
The Davids represented Karl Suleman who had induced many members of
the Assyrian community to invest in his business. This business
collapsed and many members of the Assyrian community lost