Smith v Gould [2012] VSC 461
In this issue of Expert Matters, Kellie Badge, Associate
Director of KordaMentha's Melbourne Forensic practice,
considers the judgement in a case where there was only one
accounting expert engaged. The trial judge found that the expert
was in breach of the Expert Code of Conduct by solely relying on
inadequate instructions and assumptions provided by the lawyers.
This resulted in the expert providing an opinion that was
irrelevant to the true issue in question – the value of the
interest of Mr Smith and Mr Gould ('the Parties') in the
assets in dispute – leaving the Judge to undertake the
assessment himself.
Background to the case
The case concerns the failed domestic relationship between Mr
Geoffrey Smith and Mr Robert Gould and the allocation of property
including domestic real estate, investment real estate and a
significant collection of modern Australian artwork accumulated
over a fourteen year period.1