Lewis v Shimokawa [2012] NSWCA 300
Judgment date: 24 September 2012
Jurisdiction: Court of Appeal1
In Brief
Consistent evidence of a defendant and 3 witnesses in relation
to the version of events of a motor vehicle accident, provided
under lengthy cross-examination with only minor inconsistencies in
detail, should be accepted, particularly where a court has concerns
as to the plaintiff's credit.
Background
The accident occurred on 21 November 2003 when the plaintiff
drove her vehicle into the rear of a vehicle being driven by Mr
McCaw (the first collision). This vehicle also
contained his brother and a friend. Shortly after the
plaintiff's vehicle collided with the rear of McCaw's
vehicle, the defendant's vehicle collided with the rear of the
plaintiff's vehicle (the second collision).
The defendant's wife was a passenger in his vehicle.