Malone v La Playa Nominees Pty Ltd [2021] VSC 271
As experts, it sometimes seems that litigation lawyers come in
two varieties: those who ensure that no documents (email or
otherwise) are ever communicated between expert and lawyer other
than a final report (seemingly to protect legal professional
privilege) and those who believe it will all work out in the end,
so don't worry about it. There are rarely those who sit on the
fence. But thinking in such absolutes may not result in the outcome
parties are hoping for, and not being able to prove a draft was
communicated may mean no privilege is found.
This article looks at a recent decision in the Supreme Court of
Victoria, Malone v La Playa. It was found that a
draft report prepared by an expert witness which was communicated
to their instructing solicitors was privileged, whilst another
version of the draft report, which was not communicated, was not
privileged. We also look at the reasons set out in the judgment