In yet another twist to the repercussions of the 2013 High Court
decision Andrews v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group
(Andrews), which threw the law of penalties into confusion,
the United Kingdom Supreme Court (UKSC) has handed down a decision
expressly disapproving Andrews.
Recap of the Andrews decision
In Andrews, the High Court was asked to decide whether
a payment, in this case certain bank fees, could be a penalty in
circumstances where there was no breach of contract. Importantly,
the Court was not asked to decide whether the bank fees in question
were, in fact, a penalty.
Ultimately, the Court held that a payment could be a penalty
even if there was no breach of contract (see our previous article,
What the Andrews decision means for your agency's
agreements). In coming to this conclusion, it reversed its
previous decisions and underlying reasoning on the issue, several
recent Court of Appeal decisions and the generally accepted
position in