Discussions or meetings between counsel and an expert to
review and shape a draft expert report are no longer
acceptable
A controversial ruling from a Canadian court earlier this year
could have implications for the way expert witnesses prepare their
reports (at least in Canada). In Moore v
Getahun1, a medical malpractice suit heard in the
Ontario Superior Court of Justice, the trial judge was highly
critical of the way a medical expert [Dr T] discussed a draft copy
of his report with counsel and made changes based on their
suggestions.
Discovery of the expert's notes revealed that his draft
report was discussed during a 90-minute phone call. Upon
cross-examination, Dr T said that although he was happy with his
report, counsel made 'suggestions' and he 'made the
corrections over the phone'. Counsel for the Plaintiff
submitted that it was 'inappropriate for defence counsel to
make suggestions to shape Dr T's report'. Unfortunately,
the ruling does not explain what