Unless there is an express contractual right to do so, an
insurer which has paid part of an insured's loss does not have
authority to conduct and control the insured's right to recover
their entire loss, both insured and uninsured (Johnston v Endeavour
Energy [2015] NSWSC 1117). In this case, this meant that insurers
were not authorised to file opt out notices for over 550 of their
insureds to remove them from an existing class action and commence
their own class action including the claims by those insureds.
As insurers will look to include this right, policyholders
should be cautious of insurance policy wordings which seek to
confer broad recovery rights upon an insurer, particularly where
the value of uninsured loss may be significant and when control of
the recovery action may affect priorities if the amount ultimately
recovered is not sufficient to fully recover both the insured and
uninsured losses.