In an important decision impacting enforcement actions
initiated by regulators seeking civil penalties, the High Court of
Australia has held that maximum penalties are not reserved for only
the 'worst' category of contravening conduct.
The Court's recent decision in Australian Building and
Construction Commissioner v Pattinson [2022] HCA 13 will be
relevant to enforcement actions brought against organisations or
individuals by a range of state and federal regulators, including
the ATO, ASIC, APRA, the ACCC, AUSTRAC and the Australian Building
and Construction Commissioner (ABCC).
The non-application of 'proportionality' in civil
penalty proceedings is something which regulators have argued for
in a variety of ways and cases, but the fact is that, ever since
courts started trying to apply concepts relevant to criminal
penalty analysis in civil penalty proceedings, it has resulted in
inconsistent analyses.