Legal professional privilege is a shield, not a sword;
'an immunity from the exercise of powers which would
otherwise compel the disclosure of privileged
communications'1 and not a 'legal right
which is capable of being enforced' that may 'found a cause
of action'.2
That is the summary of the High Court of Australia's
decision in Glencore International AG & Ors v Commissioner
of Taxation of the Commonwealth of Australia & Ors [2019]
HCA 26 (Decision) in which multinational commodity
trader and miner, Glencore, failed to have legally privileged
documents, that came into the hands of the Australian Taxation
Office (ATO), returned to Glencore and not relied
upon.
The key legal question for the court was to determine whether a
regulator, like the Commissioner of Taxation, could use privileged
material that had been distributed into the public by a third
party.