Ryding v Miles & Ors (No 2) [2012] NSWSC 312
Background Facts
The plaintiff, Mr Ryding, engaged in various construction and
quarry works. The four defendants were owners of land on which a
quarry was operated (the land). In the main
proceeding (Ryding v Miles & Ors [2012] NSWSC 153) Mr Ryding
claimed that he suffered loss as a result of the defendants'
failure to sign a consent form relating to a development
application to Kempsey Shire Council for the installation of a
weighbridge and associated road works on the land. The proceeding
against all four defendants was dismissed.
The defendants subsequently made submissions to the NSW Supreme
Court on costs, seeking:
- indemnity costs on the basis that (a) the plaintiff had
maintained proceedings seeking damages for a loss of opportunity
that he must have known was already lost for reasons unrelated to
the alleged breaches by the defendants, (b) the plaintiff continued
the claim in circumstances where he knew he