In this article, Caitlin Meynell, Manager from our
Melbourne office, considers a case where the expert had the
appropriate level of expertise, but her evidence was unclear about
the source of her facts and assumptions.
Beagle v Australian Capital Territory and Southern
New South Wales Rugby Union Limited [2016] ACTSC
271
In this judgment, the expert had the appropriate level of
expertise, but her evidence was unclear about the source of her
facts and assumptions. Consequently, her evidence was found to be
unreliable.
Background
John Beagle, the plaintiff, brought a quantum meruit
claim seeking reasonable remuneration for assistance that he
allegedly gave to the Australian Capital Territory and Southern New
South Wales Rugby Union ('the Brumbies').
Mr Beagle alleged he assisted the Brumbies in securing a
sponsorship deal from the Aquis group of companies
('Aquis') and that a person performing
that role ought to receive a commission of 10 to 35% of the