Medical malpractice, causation, epidemiology probabilities,
compelling medical examinations
The defendant, Northern New South Wales Local Health District,
applied for an order compelling the medical examination of the
plaintiff, Luke Pederson, by way of taking saliva samples for the
purpose of genetic analysis. This interlocutory decision concerned
the question of whether, in the exercise of the court's
discretion, orders compelling the examination should be made in the
circumstances of the case.
The plaintiff was a 10 year old boy who sued the hospital for
injuries that he suffered during his birth on 14 December 2009. As
a result of delays caused by the alleged negligence of the
hospital, the plaintiff suffered Hypoxia Ischemia Encephalopathy
(HIE) which resulted in serious disabilities. The
most significant of the disabilities was the alleged development of
Autistic Syndrome Disorder (ASD) which was
diagnosed when the plaintiff was 6 years old. The plaintiff