The High Court of Australia handed down an important decision on
the issue of apprehension of judicial bias.
Charisteas v Charisteas involved a review of the
contact, outside of court time, between a barrister appearing on
behalf of one party and the trial judge hearing the same case in
the Family Court of WA.
The High Court said:
[18] ... The apprehension of bias principle is so important to
perceptions of independence and impartiality that even the
appearance of departure from it is prohibited lest the integrity of
the judicial system be undermined .
[21] ... the hypothetical observer is a standard by which the
courts address what may appear to the public served by the courts
to be a departure from standards of impartiality and independence
which are essential to the maintenance of public confidence in the
judicial system. The hypothetical observer is not conceived of as a
lawyer but a member of the public served by the courts. It would
defy logic and render