In this week’s TGIF, we consider the dangers of
being the last one standing in ‘mothership’ preference
claims. In the recent decision of In the matter of Bias
Boating Pty Limited (receivers and managers appointed) (in
liquidation) [2019]
NSWSC 47, Black J ordered costs against a number of defendants
to a preliminary question of insolvency even though they did not
participate in the hearing of that question. The decision
highlights the need to carefully consider the strategic approach
defendants take in ‘mothership’ preference
claims.
What happened?
In 2017, the liquidator of Bias Boating Pty Ltd (in liq)
(Company) brought claims against a number of
defendants to recover alleged unfair preferences. At an early
stage in the proceedings, the Court ordered that the question of
the Company’s insolvency be determined as a preliminary
question. The liquidator settled his claims against a number
of the defendants shortly before the hearing of the