If the average punter was to solely rely on media reports on the
recent Full Bench Fair Work Commission decision in CFMMEU v Mt
Arthur Coal Pty Ltd [2021] FWCFB 6059, and unhelpful headlines
like 'policy not lawful and reasonable', then they
could be forgiven for having a false sense of the merit of
mandatory vaccination policies.
While the Commission found that Mt Arthur's direction to
workers at its Mine to be vaccinated was
'unreasonable' on this occasion, it did so on the
basis of an apparent lack of consultation in the factual
circumstances of this case.
Critically, the Full Bench found that Mt Arthur could still
implement the policy after consultation.
Undoubtedly, one of the messages from the decision is that
employers must properly consult with employees on the work health
and safety issues concerning implementing a policy on vaccination.
Failure to consult may render an otherwise lawful direction or
policy unreasonable. We will take a deeper look at