There's nothing like a captivating opening in a legal
judgment.
Lord Denning was famous for dramatic starts. His judgments
opened like the chorus in a Shakespearean play, with characters
drawn as they truly were, using their real names (not plaintiff or
defendant), couched in short sentences and punchy
one-liners.
Justice Hammerschlag, perhaps inspired by the colourful judicial
story-telling of the late Lord Denning, opened his judgment
in the recent TP ICAP Management Services (Australia) Pty
Ltd v Bradley Howell; GFI Australia Pty Ltd v Matthew
Cotton [2021] NSWSC 656 with a captivating opening
scene:
'Sydney is a beautiful city which has a vast array of
hotels, pubs, and restaurants, some in exquisitely scenic
locations. This judgment does not require the Court to resolve any
deep question of legal principle. It is essentially about the
facts. But it does contain a travelogue (perhaps even a
useful one) of the many Sydney hospitality