The Second Circuit affirmed the Southern District of New
York's dismissal of importer New Fortune Inc.'s
("NFI") claims against freight forwarders Apex Logistics
International ("Apex") and Aeroflot Airlines, on the
ground that NFI's state law claims were preempted by the
Montreal Convention.
NFI, a New York corporation that imports goods exclusively from
China, brought state common law claims for breach of contract,
breach of bailment and negligence against Apex (the freight
forwarder) and Aeroflot arising out of the delay in delivery of,
and damage to, a shipment of one million face masks transported
from China to New York.
Apex and Aeroflot argued that the Montreal Convention –
which governs the international transportation of persons, baggage,
and goods by air where the flight occurs between two signatory
nations – preempted NFI's state law claims. In granting
the defendants' motion to dismiss, the district court held that
the Montreal Convention, like its