Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 11 MARCH 2004

Recent Developments In U.S. Carrier Liability Law—In Re Complaint Of Murmansk

The liability of the carrier is one of the most important issues in maritime collision law. This article considers an oft-overlooked but nonetheless important aspect of collision liability: Both-to-blame clauses and their operation when collisions occur on United States territorial waters, and, in particular, the issues that confronted the federal district court in considering such a clause’s application in <I>In re Complaint of Murmansk Shipping Co.,</I> 2001 WL 699530 (E.D. La. 2001)

United StatesTransport
Ashton O'Dwyer
Ashton O'Dwyer

The liability of the carrier is one of the most important issues in maritime collision law. This article considers an oft-overlooked but nonetheless important aspect of collision liability: Both-to-blame clauses and their operation when collisions occur on United States territorial waters, and, in particular, the issues that confronted the federal district court in considering such a clause’s application in In re Complaint of Murmansk Shipping Co., 2001 WL 699530 (E.D. La. 2001).

The both-to-blame clause found in most ocean bills of lading comes into play when two vessels, both at fault, collide and cargo on one of the vessels is damaged, as in this case:

On August 6, 2000 the M/V Anangel Endeavor ("Anangel") collided with the M/V IVAN SUSANIN (owned by "Murmansk Shipping," hereinafter "Murmansk") on the Southwest Pass of the Mississippi River. Both vessels were at fault in causing the collision. The M/V Anangel carried a cargo of corn pursuant to a charter party and bill of

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from