Executive Summary: The Ninth Circuit has
held that the Federal Aviation Act (FAA) preempts state law
wrongful termination claims where their resolution would require
"the factfinder to intrude upon the federally occupied field
of aviation safety by deciding questions of pilot medical standards
and qualifications." Ventress v. Japan Air Lines,
2014 U.S. App. LEXIS 5821 (9th Cir. Mar. 28, 2014).
Background:
Martin Ventress worked as a flight engineer for Japan Air Lines
(JAL). He claimed that JAL retaliated against him for raising
safety concerns regarding the medical fitness of a fellow pilot to
operate an aircraft. Specifically, Ventress claimed that JAL
subjected him to unnecessary psychiatric evaluations and prevented
him from working because he had raised those safety concerns and
had submitted safety reports to several federal agencies. Ventress
sued the airline, claiming this conduct violated California's
whistle-blower statute and resulted in his