by Steven W. Block and Stephen L. Day July 2003
An ocean carrier dodges a motor carrier’s limitation of liability, or why truckers should do their own paperwork
Levi Strauss & Co. v. SeaLand, 2003 WL 21108311 (SDNY 2003)
Shipper Levi-Strauss imported a load of jeans from Honduras into the U.S. by ocean carrier SeaLand to Port Everglades, Florida. SeaLand hired motor carrier Quaker to haul the cargo to its ultimate destination in Little Rock. The ocean portion of the carriage was successful, but a thief posing as a Quaker employee disappeared with the load before it ever saw a highway.
In a series of cross motions for summary judgment before the Southern District of New York, the shipper and carriers argued damages and limitations of liability. Levi-Strauss wanted its lost profits in addition to the cargo’s manufacturing costs of some 243 grand. While lost profits are available under the Carriage of Goods by Sea Act (governing the loss per SeaLand’s bill of lading), the