Phoenix Partner
Julie E. Maurer, Phoenix Associates
David C. Clukey and
John Daller, and Chicago Associate
Thomas M. Wolf successfully opposed a petition for remand on
behalf of our defendant motor carrier client in a case before the
Northern District of Illinois involving a unique interstate
household goods move. The plaintiffs were concurrently ordered to
amend their complaint and expressly invoke 49 U.S.C. §14706
(the Carmack Amendment) in lieu of state and common law claims.
In 2012, the plaintiffs contracted for the carrier to move their
household goods from Illinois to Pennsylvania. After the carrier
took possession of the goods, the plaintiffs were uncertain about
where to move, but requested that the carrier maintain possession
of their goods until the plaintiffs decided where to reside. In
2018, the plaintiffs ultimately moved to Vermont, and a second
carrier delivered the goods. Thereafter, the plaintiffs claimed
that some of their goods were damaged