Introduction
The California Billionaire Tax Act (the “BTA”) contains multiple constitutional defects built into its design. It implicates the Due Process Clause, the Dormant Commerce Clause, and other constitutional limits in ways that could lead a court to narrow or invalidate the initiative in whole or in part. These are not theoretical objections. They arise from the BTA’s core operating rules. If enacted, the BTA would begin not as a stable source of revenue, but in extensive litigation.
Retroactivity
The BTA imposes tax liability based on California residency as of January 1, 2026, even though the measure would not be enacted until after the November 2026 election. In practical terms, it attaches consequences to conduct that occurred before the law existed.