Franklin Advisors LLC v. Sherwood Mgmt. Corp.
(In re Whyco Finishing Technology, LLC), 500 B.R. 517 (Bankr.
E.D. Mich. 2013) –
A landlord filed an amended proof of claim for ~$700,000 based
on a chapter 11 debtor's breach of a real estate
lease. The debtor's plan liquidation trustee brought an
adversary proceeding seeking to disallow or reduce the claim, and
moved for summary judgment.
The debtor's first argument was that the lease terminated
after its initial term, and did not automatically renew for an
additional term. The lease provided:
Unless the LESSEE provides the LESSOR
written notice One Hundred Eighty (180) days prior to a renewal
period, this LEASE will automatically extend in one (1) year
increments after the INITIAL PERIOD. During any occupancy
after the INITIAL PERIOD, all the same terms and conditions as set
forth in this LEASE shall apply, except the rent during any months
will be Five Hundred Dollars ($500.00) more than the