Most commercial litigators know that a circuit court will
enforce an arbitration agreement as long as a given dispute falls
within the agreement's scope. What is or is not within the
scope of an agreement, however, has not always been clear. For
example, could a court consider whether an arbitration request had
been timely filed, or whether it was barred by estoppel or laches,
or are such issues to be decided in arbitration?
The Wisconsin Supreme Court recently decided this issue in favor
of arbitration in First Weber Group, Inc. v. Synergy Real Estate
Group, LLC, a unanimous decision written by Justice Ziegler.
2015 WI 34.
The facts, in brief, are as follows. In 2008, First Weber paid a
commission to one of its real-estate brokers, James Graham. First
Weber later decided that the commission had been paid in error and
tried to recoup the funds. Graham refused to pay, and the two sides
agreed to arbitrate the dispute, as required by a realtor-industry
code. Graham