Yesterday, we began analyzing Justice Freeman's question
patterns in civil cases. Today, we analyze whether it is more
likely that Justice Freeman will ask the first question, depending
on his vote and whether he's writing an opinion.
Overall, when Justice Freeman is in the majority of an
affirmance, there's a 12.5% chance that Justice Freeman will
ask the first question of appellants, and a 7.29% chance that
he'll ask the first question of appellees. Writing the
majority opinion had no consistent impact; when Justice Freeman
wrote the majority opinion, there was a 5.26% chance that he would
ask the first question of appellants, but a 15.79% chance that he
would ask the first question of appellees. When not writing
an opinion, there was a 13.51% chance that Justice Freeman would
ask the first question of appellants, but a 5.41% chance that he
would ask the first question of appellees.