A few months ago, we discussed the
Fiorentino case where Pennsylvania plaintiffs alleged
an oil and gas company improperly conducted hydraulic fracturing,
which allowed the release of toxic chemicals on their land and into
their groundwater. At the time, the Fiorentino court was
unwilling to dismiss the plaintiffs' claims until the record
was more fully developed. Among those claims was a claim for strict
liability whereby the plaintiffs claimed that hydraulic fracturing
is an abnormally dangerous activity under Pennsylvania law.
Fiorentino v. Cabot Oil & Gas Corp., 750 F. Supp. 2d
506 (M.D. Pa. 2010). Recently, the Fiorentino court
rendered a decision declining to "take a step which no court
in the United States has chosen to take, and declare hydraulic
fracturing to be an ultra-hazardous activity that gives rise to
strict tort liability." Fiorentino, No.
3:09-cv-02284, Doc. 489 at 1.