The United States District Court for the Eastern District of
Louisiana recently issued an opinion in Bell v. Foster Wheeler
Energy Corp., CV-15-6394, Africk, L., 2016 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 137547
(E.D. La. Oct. 4, 2016) that enunciates what it calls a "third
view" on the so-called "bare metal defense" for
asbestos litigation. This "third view" introduces further
uncertainty into the ever-changing landscape of the "bare
metal defense" and would require additional analysis to
evaluate the defense's applicability to a manufacturer as
opposed to the two views that previously existed within the split
of authority.
Split of Authority Prior to Bell Decision
In Bell, the plaintiff is a former U.S. Navy engineman,
machinery repairman and machinist mate and the court analyzed the
case under maritime law. Ten defendants filed a motion for summary
judgment seeking to avoid liability on the basis of the "bare
metal defense." As the court noted in its decision, there is a
split in