Last week, the Rule 23 Subcommittee released its latest draft
proposal for amending Rule 23. (
2015-1105 Rule 23 Subcommittee Report)
The Subcommittee has abandoned (or in a few cases, placed
"on hold") several of its proposed amendments.
Among them:
- There is no longer an attempt to amend Rule
23(c)(4) to specify that it trumps Rule 23(b)(3).
- There is no longer any attempt to enshrine cy
pres relief in Rule 23.
- The attempt to add an explicit
ascertainability requirement has been placed on
hold.
- The attempt to except Rule 23 from the Rule 68 offer of
judgment has been placed on hold.
For the most part, this set of developments is good news.
The Rule 23(c)(4) proposal would have significantly changed
certification practice, and would have undermined one of the
fundamental methods of protecting due process in an opt-out class
action. Enshrining cy pres relief in the Rule would
very likely have violated the Rules Enabling Act, a risk that would
not