On March 17, 2021, Southern District of New York Judge Lorna G.
Schofield ruled that most of the 2019 Borrower Defense to Repayment
Rule would survive cross-motions for summary judgement. On one
issue, however, Judge Schofield ruled for the Plaintiff, the New
York Legal Assistance Group (NYLAG), finding that the 2019
Rule's three-year statute of limitations on defensive claims
was not a logical outgrowth of and deviated too sharply from the
2018 Notice of Proposed Rulemaking.
The decision means that most of the 2019 Rule remains intact
– for the time being. Therefore, for loans first disbursed
after July 1, 2020, the following policies survive: the standard of
relief; the rejection of the group claims; the definition of
financial harm and the types of acceptable evidence of financial
harm; the allowance for pre-dispute arbitration agreements and
class action waivers; the elimination of certain financial
responsibility disclosure requirements; and the abolition