Houston, Texas (February 15, 2022) - For almost
two decades, policyholders and insurers alike have wondered if the
Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals got it right with
its Erie guess in Northfield Ins. Co.
v. Loving Home Care, Inc., 363 F.3d 523 (5th Cir. 2004),
holding that Texas law should permit courts to consider extrinsic
evidence when determining the duty to defend. On February 11, 2022,
the Texas Supreme Court determined that it agreed with this holding
when it was presented with a certified question from the Fifth
Circuit in Monroe Guaranty Ins. Co. v. BITCO General Ins.
Corp., No. 21-0232.
The underlying matter arose from a property damage case in which
the insured was sued for negligently drilling an irrigation well
after it allegedly got a drilling bit stuck in a bore hole and then
abandoned the well. The insured stipulated as to the date on which
the bit got stuck, which was prior to the relevant policy period.
The policy did not cover continuing property