Vigilantibus non
dormientibus, æquitas subvenit.
It's an ancient principle of
equity, drawn from Roman law: Equity relieves the vigilant, not
those who sleep upon their rights. And it sums up quite well the
Seventh Circuit's recent decision in SEC v. First Choice
Management Services, Nos. 14-1270 & 14-2284 (Sept. 11,
2014). First Choice did not involve equity (or even
cite the maxim); it concerned an untimely motion to intervene. But
the principle was the same, and it's a good lesson for
potential intervenors.
The court, in an opinion written by
Judge Posner, affirmed the district court's denial of a motion
to intervene as untimely in a receivership proceeding. The proposed
intervenor knew that the receiver proposed to sell the property to
which the intervenor had an adverse claim six months before the
intervenor sought to intervene. Judge Posner and the Seventh
Circuit were unwilling to brook that sort of "dawdling,"
which created only more work for the