When we head into a trial against a personal injury plaintiff,
our client, the defendant, occupies the right side of the v. We
mean that simply as a matter of word placement. It is Plaintiff v.
Defendant, not the other way around (though on appeal the parties
can be scrambled). By "right" side, we are not
necessarily making a claim as to legal, moral, or aesthetic
primacy. Nor are we asking for sympathy. If the case turns on
whether tender feelings of jurors will flow toward a grievously ill
plaintiff or a defendant corporation, we know that we will finish
in second place. That's okay. As Hyman Roth said, "This is the business we've
chosen."
But sometimes the sympathy factor can make what is already an
uphill run seem nearly impossible. Consider the case of Ward v.
LiNa Med. USA, Inc., et al., 2021 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 3096
(S.D.W.Va. Jan. 5, 2021). In Ward, the plaintiff had
undergone a hysterectomy via a power morcellator. A morcellator
uses spinning blades to mince