Today's case originated in the pelvic mesh MDL pending in
the Southern District of West Virginia. Approximately one
year ago, the matter was transferred to plaintiff's home
jurisdiction in Florida. Accompanying the case upon transfer
was defendant's motion for partial summary judgment on four
of plaintiff's claims. Plaintiff abandoned three of
those claims (strict liability manufacturing defect, breach of
express warranty, and breach of implied warranty), leaving only
plaintiff's failure to warn claim to be decided
by Swintelski v. American Medical Systems, Inc.,
— F.Supp.3d —, 2021 WL 687202 (S.D. Fla. Feb. 22,
2021).
The facts of the case are straightforward. Plaintiff
underwent surgery during which her surgeon implanted
defendant's pelvic mesh product. She alleges she
suffered adverse health effects
thereafter. Id. at *1. At the core
of the matter, however, is the testimony of her implanting surgeon
– the learned intermediary. The implanter