The U.S. Supreme Court today decided unanimously that, when
cases are consolidated under Fed. R. Civ. P. 42(a), they
nevertheless remain separate cases. In
Hall v. Hall, No. 16-1150, two separate cases had been
consolidated and were tried together to a jury, but the district
court granted a new trial in one of the cases and entered a final
judgment in the other. After the losing party in the decided case
took an appeal, the Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit held
that, because of the consolidation, the judgment appealed from was
not a "final decision" under 28 U.S.C. § 1291.
It dismissed the appeal for lack of jurisdiction.
In an opinion by Chief Justice Roberts, the Supreme Court
reviewed the history of consolidation in federal practice,
beginning with a statute enacted in 1813, which remained in effect
in some form until replaced by Rule 42(a) in 1937. It concluded
from the cases interpreting the statute that consolidation was not
intended to effect a merger