Most courts offer a second chance to litigants who have withheld
arguably protected documents, but who prepare a tardy or inadequate
privilege log. However, courts quickly lose patience with litigants
who seem to flout the rules.
In McNamee v. Clemens, former New York Yankees pitcher
and defamation defendant Roger Clemens withheld documents, but
relied "on a one-sentence assertion of privilege" rather
than supplying the required privilege log. No. 09 CV 1647 (SJ)
(CLP), 2014 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 46338, at *12 (E.D.N.Y. Apr. 2, 2014).
The Magistrate Judge had (1) reminded Clemens of the log
requirement; (2) invited Clemens to provide a further showing to
support his withholding (which Clemens "was only able to do so
with respect to one document"); and (3) "took the
extraordinary step of reviewing each and every document that
Defendant claimed was privileged." Id. at *14 n.6.
The District Judge upheld the Magistrate Judge's finding that
Clemens had waived any privilege or